Andie Swimwear Review: Stylish Simplicity or Swimwear That Falls Flat?

Andie Swim

Shopping for a swimsuit can feel like a high-stakes treasure hunt. You want something flattering, supportive, and stylish—but not over the top. Discover Andie Swim, a brand that’s making waves on social media for its minimalist swimsuits, size-inclusive cuts, and “made for real women” look.

But does the brand actually deliver on its promises, or is it just another well-marketed swimwear line riding the wave of influencer hype?

We tried out some of Andie’s most popular models and put them through their paces – from the beach to the garden lounger. Here’s our in-depth, unfiltered review: What worked, what didn’t, and whether Andie Swimwear is really worth the money.

🔍 About Andie Swim: The Brand Behind the Buzz

Andie Swim was founded in 2017 by Melanie Travis. The brand was born out of frustration with the difficulty of finding a simple, flattering, and high-quality swimsuit online. The brand positions itself as a direct-to-consumer solution for women who want classic swimwear without the retail markup or confusing fit.

What sets Andie apart:

  • Designed by women for women
  • Extensive fit testing on real body types
  • Clean, timeless silhouettes (no noticeable necklines or other gimmicks)
  • A home fitting program (for testing fits before purchasing)

They also offer inclusive sizes (from XS-XXXL), long torso options, and suits that focus more on function and comfort than flashy embellishments.

Pros

  • Elegant, timeless designs
  • Soft, durable, high-quality fabrics
  • Inclusive sizing and long torso options
  • Try-at-home program for hassle-free sizing
  • Eco-friendly fabric options

Cons

  • Some styles lack bust support
  • Long torso fits can run short
  • Prices higher than fast-fashion brands
  • Limited print/color variety in some collections
  • High-waisted bottoms may not suit shorter torsos

🌊 Our Full Review: Breaking Down the Latest from Andie Swim

We got our hands on (and on) eight standout pieces from Andie Swim’s latest collection—including new checks, eco-friendly fabrics, and sleek silhouettes. Below, you’ll find our in-depth, honest review of how each piece performed, how it fits, and whether it deserves a spot in our beach bag.

👙 The Amalfi One-Piece – Sierra Plaid
Price: $142
Signature Plaid | Fully Lined | Moderate Bottom Coverage
This suit is a sweet mix of retro and modern. The Sierra Plaid is playful without being loud, and the square neckline feels both elegant and secure. The straps are adjustable, the shelf bra adds light support, and the overall cut flatters both athletic and curvier shapes.
💬 “Felt like a vintage postcard come to life—but comfy!”
Shop Now
💧 The Elwood One Piece
Price: $122
Eco Nylon | Adjustable Straps | Shelf Bra
The Elwood is Andie’s sporty girl essential. The Cyan color pops against any skin tone, and the fit feels somewhere between a swimsuit and a unitard—in the best way. It’s simple, comfy, and easy to wear all day. Think lap swimming, paddleboarding, or chasing toddlers.
💬 “Like your favorite bodysuit, but for the beach.”
Shop Now
🖤 The Pana One Piece
Price: $112
Eco Nylon | High Neck | Open Back
Chic, minimal, and surprisingly sexy, the Pana gives full coverage in the front with a sultry open back. It’s perfect for those who want sun protection on the chest but still want to show some skin. The eco fabric feels luxe and dries quickly.
💬 “A power suit disguised as a swimsuit.”
Shop Now
🖤 The Amalfi One Piece Black Classic
Price: $128
Ribbed Stretch Nylon | Adjustable Straps | Built-in Shelf Bra
This version of the Amalfi is pure elegance. The ribbed black fabric gives it a structured, elevated feel, and the square neckline adds instant polish. It’s an understated piece you can wear year after year without it going out of style.
💬 “It’s giving Old Hollywood—without sacrificing comfort.”
Shop Now
💙 The Bells Bikini Top
Price: $68
Triangle Halter | Ties at Neck and Back
Your classic triangle top—but upgraded with better fabric and fit. The Cyan hue is vibrant and youthful, and the cut offers solid coverage while still keeping things flirty. We loved how adjustable it is—especially for uneven busts.
💬 “Finally, a triangle top that doesn’t feel like it’ll fall off when I dive in.”
Shop Now
💙 The Bells Bikini Bottom
Price: $56
Low Rise | Classic Cut | Medium Coverage
Pairs perfectly with the Bells top. The cut hits just right—not too cheeky, not too full. It sits low on the hips and feels super lightweight on the skin. Ideal for sunning, swimming, or slipping under shorts for a day out.
💬 “The kind of bottom that feels like second skin.”
Shop Now
💜 The Rye Bikini Top
Price: $78
Underwire Support | Adjustable Straps | Back Clasp
This one’s a gem if you want structured support without looking matronly. The underwire and fuller coverage give major lift without digging in. The plaid adds a fun, slightly preppy twist that still feels on-trend.
💬 “Lift, shape, and cuteness all in one—finally!”
Shop Now
💜 The Classic Bikini Bottom
Price: $64
Mid Rise | Moderate Coverage | Clean Finish
The Classic Bottom lives up to its name. Clean lines, moderate rear coverage, and no-fuss design. The mid-rise sits comfortably—not too high, not too low. Paired with the Rye top, it makes for a polished, supportive set.
💬 “Zero tugging. Zero wedgies. Just cute and comfy.”
Shop Now

📦 Shipping, Returns & Fit Finder: What to Know Before You Order?

🚚 Shipping Policy: Smooth and Straightforward

Andie Swim keeps shipping refreshingly simple. Here’s what you can expect:

  • Free shipping to the US on all orders over $100.
  • Standard shipping takes approximately 5-8 business days.
  • Need it faster? Express shipping is available for an additional charge at checkout (typically 2-3 days, depending on location).
  • We ship from the US, so domestic orders are fast and reliable.
  • International shipping is available, but delivery times and costs vary depending on the destination (duties and taxes may apply).

If you are ordering for a holiday or special occasion, we recommend express shipping for security reasons, especially during peak season.

🔁 Returns & Exchanges: Hassle-Free and Generous

We’ve all been there: The swimsuit you thought would suit you doesn’t. With Andie, you can easily exchange or return it—hassle-free.

Here are the details:

  • 30-day return policy from receipt of your order
  • Items must be unworn, unwashed, and with tags and sanitary liner attached.
  • Returns are free within the US using the enclosed, prepaid return label.
  • You can return the item for a refund or exchange it for a different size, color, or style.
  • Returns are processed quickly—refunds are typically received within 5–10 days.

Additionally, Andie offers you a credit note if you choose an exchange instead of a refund (great if you plan on ordering another suit anyway).

🛑 Important Note: Final Sale items are not eligible for returns or exchanges—so double-check the product listing before purchasing. sfsdfsfsfdf

👙 Fit Finder Quiz: Surprisingly Accurate

One of Andie Swim’s best features is the Fit Finder quiz – a short, 1-minute questionnaire that will guide you to your perfect size and style.

You will be asked for:

  • Your height and weight
  • Bra and panty size
  • Desired coverage (minimal or full)
  • Preference for breast support
  • Activity level (folding or swimming)

The great thing about it is that there isn’t just one item recommended, but there are multiple styles and even flags to choose from if a longer torso version might suit you better.

Bonus: You can create an account to save your fit profile for future orders, which is especially helpful if you’re building a swimwear wardrobe. saadasddads

🙋‍♀️ What Customers Are Saying?

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“I’ve never felt more confident in a swimsuit. The Snap One-Piece is perfection. I wear it chasing toddlers around and still feel chic.”
– Nicole S.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Love the styles, but wish the support was a bit stronger in the bust. Still, the fabric and cuts are beautiful.”
– Amanda R.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“The quality blew me away. I used to buy $30 suits, but now I see the difference. Worth the investment.”
– Jada M.

🧼 Care Tips for Longevity

How to keep your Andie suit in top shape:

  • Rinse immediately after bathing in chlorine or salt water.
  • Hand wash with cold water and a mild detergent.
  • Do not wring or tumble dry.
  • Dry flat in the shade.

🧵 Final Verdict: Stylish Simplicity That Mostly Delivers

So, does Andie Swimwear live up to its clean-cut promise?

Yes – mostly. The fabrics feel luxurious, the cuts are thoughtful, and the minimalist aesthetic makes these suits timeless staples. While bust support and fit variations may be an issue for some, most women find at least one style that feels tailor-made.

If you’re tired of over-designed, overly revealing swimsuits and just want something flattering, comfortable, and stylish, Andie Swim is definitely worth a try.