Facebook Instagram Medium Tiktok

McGee & Co Review: Is the Dreamy Home Style Worth the Price Tag?

ribbon
Get 15% Off Your Order Sitewide

Get 15% Off Your Order Sitewide

Get 15% Off Your Order Sitewide
DT_BRASSMEMBER
SHOW COUPON
On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • Get 10% Off Your Order Over $100+ Purchase

    Get 10% Off Your Order Over $100+ Purchase

    Get 10% Off Your Order Over $100+ Purchase
    15OFFFALL25
    SHOW COUPON
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • Signup & Get 15% Off Your First Purchase

    Signup & Get 15% Off Your First Purchase

    Signup & Get 15% Off Your First Purchase
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • ribbon
    Sale! Save Upto 50% Off On Selective

    Sale! Save Upto 50% Off On Selective

    Sale! Save Upto 50% Off On Selective
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • ribbon
    Hurry! Save 15% Off On Bed & Bath

    Hurry! Save 15% Off On Bed & Bath

    Hurry! Save 15% Off On Bed & Bath
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • Save 30% Off On Bodie Fiberstone Planter

    Save 30% Off On Bodie Fiberstone Planter

    Save 30% Off On Bodie Fiberstone Planter
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • Shop Our Best Sellers Collections Starting As Low As $3.00

    Shop Our Best Sellers Collections Starting As Low As $3.00

    Shop Our Best Sellers Collections Starting As Low As $3.00
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • Shop Our Wool Rugs Collections Starts As Low As $21.75

    Shop Our Wool Rugs Collections Starts As Low As $21.75

    Shop Our Best Selling Rugs Collections Starts As Low As $21.75
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • Explore Our New In Collection Starting From $12

    Explore Our New In Collection Starting From $12

    Explore Our New In Collection Starting From $12
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
    • McGee-Co-Image

    McGee & Co. is a home furnishings and decoration brand founded by a designer couple, offering a wide range of furniture, lighting, rugs and smaller decorative accessories.

    Their aesthetic strongly tends towards a “modern-rustic / modern country house / transitional” atmosphere – warm, neutral tones, cozy textures and classic shapes.

    Essentially, McGee & Co. positions itself as the first point of contact for people who want a carefully curated “designer home” look without the prices of a custom-designed house (or at least that is the goal).

    Pros

    • Curated aesthetic and cohesive design language — McGee & Co. leans into a transitional / modern-rustic style that many homeowners and interior-style seekers find appealing. Their pieces tend to coordinate well, which helps create a unified “designed” look across rooms.
    • Wide selection across categories — From stools and chairs, to beds, rugs, and lighting — the brand offers a full spectrum of home furnishings, making it convenient to furnish or style an entire space under one brand umbrella.
    • Mid-to-upper market positioning — Their pieces are positioned as mid-high quality (i.e. nicer than budget/furniture-store mass-market, at least on a design level), providing an “upgrade feel” when decorating a home.
    • Structured shipping and delivery logistics — McGee & Co. clearly separates how they deliver small items vs. large furniture (doorstep delivery vs. threshold/white-glove for big items), which helps set expectations for customers ordering larger pieces.

    Cons

    • Inconsistent quality and durability (especially on heavy-use items) — Many customer reviews highlight problems: furniture that falls apart, stools or chairs that become unstable, or items whose build/material feels cheaper than expected for the price.
    • Customer service — shipping & fulfillment problems, slow or incomplete deliveries — There are recurring complaints about delayed shipping, partial deliveries (some items arriving, others delayed), unclear backorders, or unresponsive customer service.
    • Strict return / “final sale” rules for many items — Furniture (especially larger or custom-upholstered furniture), as well as rugs, lighting, art, or “final sale” items generally aren’t returnable. That increases risk if the piece doesn’t meet expectations or arrives flawed.
    • Value-for-money concerns — Given reports of quality issues and the high price point, many customers feel they pay a premium for appearance more than long-term build/value — which raises questions about whether the “look” is worth the cost.
    • Uncertain long-term support or warranty reliability — While some sources list a “furniture product warranty,” many real-world customers report difficulties getting help when something breaks after the return window — suggesting warranty enforcement or support is inconsistent.

    🏡 What appeals — Style, vibe & aesthetic value

    • Timeless, neutral, cozy aesthetic: Many buyers rave that McGee & Co.’s pieces “look more expensive than they are,” and that the warm woods, subtle textures, and soft color palettes convey a sense of quiet elegance.
    • A holistic living concept: Since McGee offers everything from large pieces of furniture to small decorative items (lamps, bookends, rugs, etc.), several coordinated pieces can be purchased – contributing to a harmonious overall look in a room or throughout the entire house. Some users describe the combination of these elements as successful, giving them an elegant, almost hotel-like appearance.
    • Affordable “designer” flair (at least visually): McGee & Co. offers many people an easy way to achieve a designer-inspired look without the hassle of sourcing individual pieces or having custom-made furniture created. This convenience – combined with sophisticated design – accounts for much of the brand’s appeal.
    In short: If appearance and atmosphere are important to you – a calm, well-maintained ambiance like in a home magazine – then McGee & Co. often delivers on its promises.

    ✅ Where McGee & Co. delivers — Products that tend to satisfy

    From customer feedback in several reviews:

    • Smaller decorative items such as bookends, lamps, and accessories seem to be meeting expectations. One buyer described marble bookends as “functional and beautiful,” while another said table lamps pleasantly enhanced the ambiance of his living space.
    • For those who want to furnish a room stylishly (rather than buying furniture to last forever), McGee offers a straightforward and practical package with its furniture and decorations. One customer reported that their decorative piece “adds just the right touch of color” and blends in harmoniously instead of clashing with the rest of the room.
    Essentially, smaller to medium-sized decorative purchases – rather than expensive furniture – satisfy most customers when considering style and visual coherence.

    ⚠️ Common pitfalls — Complaints, quality & service concerns

    However, several recurring criticisms give cause for concern. The negative aspects focus primarily on quality, value for money, and customer service/delivery. Main topics:

    • Inconsistent quality: Some customers report serious problems – e.g., furniture that “falls apart”, carpets with missing threads, or items that look completely different (color, texture) than advertised.
    • Poor customer service and delivery delays: Many reviewers complain about unresponsive customer support, automated bot responses, long shipping or delivery delays, and unsatisfactory solutions to problems that arise.
    • The prices do not always reflect reality: given the brand’s positioning and pricing, many feel they are paying mid- to high-priced items while the quality is only mediocre – especially when compared to custom-made or handcrafted furniture of similar cost.
    • Lack of transparency and flexibility regarding returns: Complaints about the absence of price adjustments after discounts, strict return policies (especially for furniture), or the refusal to acknowledge defects – even when they appear obvious – are not uncommon.
    In other words, while McGee & Co. offers stylish furniture, it often struggles with durability, longevity, and customer service. For larger purchases (sofas, chairs, rugs), this can make the value for money questionable.

    🪑 Product-Specific Reviews

    Here’s a look at some popular tracks by McGee & Co., what works – and what I think you should pay attention to.

    Fielder Counter Stool

    Fielder Counter Stool

    Pros

    • This stool impresses with its clean, minimalist design, featuring a handcrafted white oak frame and tapered legs. Its simplicity makes it versatile – it fits perfectly in modern kitchens, minimalist spaces, or Scandinavian-inspired interiors. Because it's a stool (and not a heavy sofa or bed), the construction is less complex, minimizing the risk should the manufacturer's workmanship vary.

    Cons

    • The price is quite high for what is essentially a simple stool. Since stools are subject to frequent use (sitting, sliding), their durability and stability are questionable. Furthermore, as the stool is handmade, the surface and appearance can vary from piece to piece (some may look slightly different from the online photos).
    Verdict: A good choice if you're looking for a stylish, design-oriented stool for a less frequently used area (e.g., for occasional seating at the breakfast bar). Not ideal for everyday use or if you're looking for a stool to last a lifetime – think of it more as a decorative object than an heirloom.
    Shop Now

    Fenwick Lounge Chair

    Fenwick Lounge Chair

    Pros

    • Lounge chairs like this one add comfort and style to living rooms, reading nooks, or bedroom corners. Provided the design complements McGee's neutral, timeless aesthetic, the chair will likely contribute to a harmonious overall look. For occasional seating (guests, light use), it serves as an excellent design object and not just a functional piece of furniture.

    Cons

    • Given the widespread reports of quality issues and structural defects in McGee furniture, intensive, daily use can lead to instability or premature wear. Furthermore, McGee furniture is often sold under strict "final sale" terms – meaning that if the chair is delivered and does not meet expectations (comfort, workmanship, color), a return or exchange may not be possible.
    Verdict: Well-suited as a focal point or accent chair – ideally in rooms where it will only be used infrequently or occasionally. For daily use as a primary seating option, you shouldn't expect too much in terms of durability.
    Shop Now

    Denning Upholstered Bed

    Denning Upholstered Bed

    Pros

    • Upholstered beds generally lend bedrooms softness, warmth, and a cozy, elegant atmosphere. For those who prefer a stylish, rustic-modern, or rustic-classic interior design, this bed can harmoniously complement the room's decor. It typically appears more luxurious than a simple metal or wooden bed frame.

    Cons

    • Large pieces of furniture like beds are among the most problematic when quality control or material standards are lacking. Given McGee & Co.'s mixed reputation regarding workmanship and durability, there's a real risk: uneven upholstery, potential instability, or wear and tear over time. Furthermore—and this is a crucial point—this type of furniture is often non-returnable, meaning you have to live with what you receive. This is a significant disadvantage if something goes wrong.
    Verdict: If you're planning a bedroom primarily focused on aesthetics and low wear and tear (master bedroom, guest room, infrequently used room), this bed might meet your needs. However, I would hesitate if I required a robust and durable bed or wanted the option to return it.
    Shop Now

    Gemma Lounge Chair

    Gemma Lounge Chair

    Pros

    • This chair, available for immediate delivery, offers exceptional comfort (no long waiting times like with some custom-made or backordered items). Like many McGee furniture pieces, it likely bears the brand's unmistakable signature style – making it an ideal focal point in the living room, studio, or home office. Perfect for both decorative and occasional use.

    Cons

    • Durability and build quality are also questionable here. Given frequent customer complaints about furniture (chairs, stools) that wears out quickly or looks cheap relative to its price, the Gemma chair is probably best suited as a purely decorative item. Furthermore, return options are limited if the chair doesn't meet expectations.
    Verdict: A good choice if you're looking for a chair for occasional use (e.g., as an accent chair or for occasional guests). Not ideal for daily use or high durability.
    Shop Now

    Conway Handwoven Wool Rug

    Conway Handwoven Wool Rug

    Pros

    • Rugs are often the finishing touch that gives a room its final flair – a handwoven rug from McGee can add structure, warmth, and an elegant touch to living rooms or bedrooms. In rooms with low to medium traffic, it offers a perfect balance between aesthetics and functionality.

    Cons

    • McGee rugs, like other items, can have quality defects: irregularities in the weave, variations in color/texture compared to the photos, or problems with the workmanship. Furthermore, a processing fee is charged for returned rugs (and lamps), and the rugs must be unused and in their original packaging – which is often inconvenient after they've been laid out.
    Verdict: Suitable for decoratively designed rooms, especially with careful use (low wear and tear). Riskier when used in high-traffic areas or when a long lifespan for the carpet is expected.
    Shop Now

    📦 Shipping, Return & Warranty

    Shipping

    • McGee & Co. offers various delivery methods: Small decorative items and small furniture (such as armchairs and stools) are delivered to the front door. Larger furniture pieces (beds, large furniture, custom-made upholstered furniture) are delivered via curbside delivery or with a “white glove” service – the recipients are contacted to arrange a delivery date.
    • Each item is shipped from US distribution centers. International shipping is not available: The brand explicitly does not ship furniture, artwork, lamps, or rugs to countries outside the USA.
    • If items arrive damaged, the delivery person should note the damage on the delivery slip, and the customer must contact the company within 48 hours to initiate a damage claim.

    Return Policy

    • Returns of selected items are possible within 30 days of delivery.
    • The customer bears the costs for return shipping. If the return is for reasons other than damage (e.g., buyer’s change of heart), the original shipping costs will not be refunded.
    • A 15% restocking fee will be charged for returned furniture and larger items (provided the item meets the relevant conditions). A 15% restocking fee also applies to carpets and lamps. These items must be unused, unassembled, and in their original packaging. Custom-made upholstered furniture, special orders, and clearance/end-of-season sale items are generally non-returnable.
    • Refunds (if accepted) will be issued via the original payment method, less shipping and handling fees. Processing time is typically 3–5 business days after receipt of the return.

    Warranty Policy

    • According to an overview, McGee & Co. lists products of medium to high quality and offers a “furniture product guarantee”.
    • However, many customer reviews and feedback threads show that warranty handling after the return period has expired is inconsistent. If structural or quality defects appear months later, customers often report difficulties obtaining a satisfactory solution.
    • Therefore, it can happen that although a guarantee exists in name, its enforcement in practice varies greatly.
    🤔 FAQs:
    Can I order McGee & Co furniture/rugs to Pakistan (or outside USA)?

    Officially — no. McGee & Co does not ship furniture, rugs, lighting or artwork outside the U.S.

    What happens if an item arrives damaged?

    If damage is noted on the delivery receipt and you contact McGee & Co within 48 hours (with photos and order info), they will attempt to handle the damage claim — potentially via a refund or replacement (depending on item type and availability) under their damaged-item policy.

    Can I return furniture or rugs if I change my mind?

    For some items yes — but returns come with conditions: 30-day window, customer pays return shipping, and large items incur a 15% restocking fee. Rugs and lighting also have a 15% restocking fee and must be unused and in original packaging. Custom, clearance or final-sale items are usually not returnable.

    Is there long-term warranty or support if furniture breaks after months?

    While McGee & Co lists a “furniture product warranty” in some overviews, many customers report poor post-purchase support once the 30-day return window closes — so warranty reliability appears to be inconsistent.

    Are there differences in delivery method depending on the item ordered?

    Yes — small items (decor, small furniture) get doorstep delivery; large furniture, beds, or custom upholstery are delivered via threshold or white-glove service (with scheduled delivery).

    💭 Verdict — Is McGee & Co worth it?

    Maybe — but only if you approach with realistic expectations.

    If your main goal is to achieve a stylish, cohesive home aesthetic with minimal effort – particularly through decoration, lighting, rugs and smaller pieces of furniture – McGee & Co. can absolutely provide you with a “designer home” ambience that looks good in photos and feels warm and carefully designed.

    However, those investing in heavily used furniture (sofas, dining chairs, large tables, carpets for high-traffic areas) or expecting maximum durability and excellent customer service will often be disappointed by McGee & Co. Fluctuations in materials, workmanship, and support are so frequent that the risk of disappointment should not be underestimated.

    In short: McGee & Co. impresses with its atmosphere and aesthetics – just think of its “appearance”. However, there is a compromise in terms of value for money, quality and reliability. Whether it’s worth it depends on what you buy and what you value.